Musing On Negative Attitudes Towards Benefit Claimants From Working People

A while back I was called in by Maximus to go on a job search group session. Whilst I was waiting there for the session to start a young woman who was also attending was complaining about the fact she had been told to attend and that she was annoyed about the amount of times she is being called in by Maximums every week because she never gets to spend time with her young relatives.

I gathered she was in JSA and I felt sorry for her as it was obvious that the Work Programme was putting on the pressure on her to find work by making her attend as many times in a week as they could.

Then I got thinking what kind of reaction so many people out there amongst the general public would have to her complaints and the kind of hostile attitudes she would get.

They would tell her that she shouldn’t be able to spend time with her family because she’s claiming benefits and she’s supposed to be looking for a job. There would be people asking why should be able to spend time with her family whilst living off the money of “hard working taxpayers”.

There would be working people who would tell her that they don’t get to spend much time with their families as they have to work long hours to pay their bills and put food on their tables and that she should feel lucky that because she is unemployed she gets to see her family more than they do theirs.

They would call her a “scrounger” and tell her to stop complaining and go get a job because that’s what she is being paid by the government to do.

The reason I am talking about this woman and all this is because these are the nasty kind of attitudes people on benefits have to endure from sections of the public who have jobs. And these attitudes are created by the government and the media who pit the working and the non working ordinary people against each other.

They tell working people that whilst they work hard for long hours the unemployed sit around doing whatever they want with lots of time on their hands and lots of money for cigarettes, booze and Sky TV.

It’s this kind of rhetoric and propaganda that creates the nasty attitudes towards the unemployed and people on benefits which turns ordinary people against each other.

We must resist the attempts by the government and the media to divide us because anyone of us could find ourselves needing to claim benefits in our lives,


3 thoughts on “Musing On Negative Attitudes Towards Benefit Claimants From Working People

  1. If only it was just down to the media and the Government. Alas, it is not and to say otherwise is to ignore the fact that some people have been calling those receiving benefits scroungers since the late 16th Century.

    I worked in a Jobcentre and I had people receiving JSA telling me that other people on JSA were scrounging, but not them. I had more than one person tell me that if they were black or Asian they would get more JSA per week, because, in their opinion, there were higher, unpublished, rates for non whites.

    There is a mentality amongst some, regardless of class, along the lines of there is someone, somewhere, out there getting money to which they are not entitled (or entitled) which I cannot get (or ‘virtuously’ choose not to claim) and for which I am paying (and for which I object paying). We will not address that mentality by taking the easy way out by placing the blame for its existence solely on certain parts of the media and political parties.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s